John Kenneth Muir, a prolific writer and unabashed fan of the genre TV and movies of the 1970s and ’80s, has a few comments inspired by that Star Trek reboot trailer I mentioned on Friday. While I’m not as receptive to this project as he seems to be, he nevertheless hits several nails squarely on their heads, and he even manages to give me a new perspective on how and why Abrams-Trek (as I’m starting to think of this project) may be a good thing:
In the months ahead, we’re all going to be tempted to second guess the new movie. Is the right actor playing young Kirk? Do the Vulcans look like Romulans? Where is Gary Mitchell? Didn’t Kirk serve on the Farragut before serving on the Enterprise? That’s what fans like us do. We can’t help it. I know I can’t help it.
…I want a faithful Star Trek movie, but at the same time, I desperately want a Star Trek movie that my son Joel, when he is old enough, will love. I want a film that will inspire a generation of kids. I want today’s kids to grow up with a reinvigorated, exciting, adventurous and bold Star Trek…a moral, progressive and heartfelt franchise like the one I grew up with and which, in many ways, made me the person I am today. I don’t want Next Gen political correctness, I don’t want the Love Boat in Space where the crew’s family beams up to the Enterprise to go through some uninspiring family drama. I don’t want fictional adventures in Holodecks…that’s masturbation, not boldly going. And I don’t want the United Nations in Space. I want what Star Trek was once about: space exploration….going where no man has gone before. I want excitement, adventure, and heart. I want Captain Horatio Hornblower in space again…not some kind of incestuous, insular vision that only a few die-hard Trekkies can appreciate. We must re-define faithful, I believe, in this case. I want a film that is faithful to Star Trek‘s pioneer spirit and Star Trek‘s swashbuckling heart. If I get that, but Kirk never served on the Farragut, well…so be it.
Much of the bloviating I’ve done on Star Trek over the years has been along these same lines, if not in these exact words: in my opinion, what all the spin-offs lacked and what the franchise drifted farther and farther away from over time is what Muir terms a pioneer spirit and a swashbuckling heart. (Thanks, John, for giving me the framing that I’ve never quite managed to articulate!) I would dearly love to see a film or television series that successfully resurrects that same spirit and heart, that inspires kids to look to the future with hope and imagination instead of indifference or fear, and which makes cynical old farts like me feel young and wide-eyed again.
Continue Reading…