Back in the mid-1990s, I found myself having a bit of an identity crisis.
(I know, I know, “What else is new, Bennion?” The truth is, I’ve had a lot of such crises over the years.)
I was finished with college and had no idea what to do with my life, or even of how to start addressing that question. I’d left my happy movie theater job for one that was supposedly more grown-up but which I didn’t like at all. And my love life was… complicated. Basically, I was in that weird liminal space where you’re not a kid anymore but you sure as hell can’t claim to be anything resembling an adult, and everything is just kind of disappointing… not least of which is yourself. Even music had let me down, as grunge had taken over everything and I didn’t like that stuff AT ALL.
Then one morning as I suffered through my commute — another aspect of adult life I was struggling with, and never would really come to terms with — I discovered The Mountain. That is, a radio station called The Mountain. KUMT, 105.7. It was a really weird, expansive format, kind of like college radio without the aggressive pretentiousness… a mish-mash of classic rock, blues, folk, adult contempo, alternative, outlaw country, alt-country, genres I didn’t have a name for. Hits and album tracks alike, new singles by artists who hadn’t had a hit in years but were still recording, and songs by artists who’d never come anywhere near a chart. It was simply GOOD music. It was probably the best radio station we ever had in the Salt Lake area. I discovered a lot of artists listening to The Mountain. And among them was a cat named Todd Snider.
He was a singer-songwriter with kind of a country sound, only not really — he was just doing his own thing — and a big sense of humor. He reminded me a bit of early Jimmy Buffett, which made sense since he was recording at that time on Jimmy’s Margaritaville Records label. I bought his first album, Songs for the Daily Planet, after hearing three or four tracks on The Mountain, and I played the hell out of it for six or eight months. I’m not going to say that Todd Snider saved me during a dark time or anything dramatic like that. But he did brighten my days when I needed it, and his clever, sassy, sometimes poignant lyrics about exactly where Generation X was standing at that point in time assured me I wasn’t quite as lost as I often felt in those days. Two songs in particular stood out: “Talkin’ Seattle Grunge Rock Blues,” an unlisted or “hidden” track at the end of the CD (remember those?) had a lot of fun taking the piss out of the whole grunge scene that I hated so much. And then there was “Alright Guy,” a first-person meditation from a twentysomething dude who kept hearing from everyone around him that he was an enormous loser, but he just didn’t see it. It was a funny song and fun to sing along to, and for a while there it was a bit of an anthem for me, another young man who was flailing hard but wanted to believe he was… well, an alright guy.
And then time rolled on. I quit the job I hated and wound up in one that wasn’t much better, then eventually stumbled into one that I now see was the beginning of whatever my career has ended up being. The Mountain didn’t last too long, sadly; it was too good for a commercialized system that wants to put everything into neat little boxes. And I mostly lost track of Todd Snider. I was dimly aware that he was still out there, still recording, and that he’d found a niche for himself. I knew that he played Salt Lake’s State Room just about every year, and I often thought that I ought to go see him, for old times’ sake and so I could sing along to “Alright Guy” with him live. But I never did.
He was scheduled to play the State Room again just two weeks ago, but the performance — and then the whole damn tour — was cancelled following some kind of bizarre incident in which Todd was supposedly assaulted outside his Salt Lake hotel room and then got into an argument with hospital staffers after they discharged him against his wishes. Yesterday, I heard that he was being rushed to the hospital with double pneumonia. And this morning, I read that he’s gone, dead at the age of 59.
There are a lot of unanswered questions about that incident two weeks ago. Something sounds fishy to me, and I wonder just what exactly happened. But mostly I feel sad that a talented man has left the world with things yet to do, that I somehow lost him after his second album, and that I never got around to seeing him live. I find myself thinking a lot about the 1990s and the decade of my twenties, and about that job I hated and how awful I felt about myself and how I wanted to believe I was an alright guy. I still want to believe that. And whatever the hell happened to Todd Snider here in Salt Lake, I think he was an alright guy too.
“I just want to live until I’ve got to die
I know I ain’t perfect, but God knows I try”

